The recent discovery of a classic, rare, and dusty 1937 Bugatti in an old English garage got me thinking.
The Bugatti fits neatly into the popular imagination as a kind of "discovery tale". Discovery tales are those romantic, hopeful stories about finding some valuable piece of treasure in an unexpected place.
The discovery tale permeates our culture:
- The Rembrandt (or Picasso) in the attic
- The winning Lotto ticket
- The mid-19th-century stock certificate left by a long-lost aunt
- The pot of gold at the end of the rainbow
- The gambler who wins the big jackpot in Vegas
- The starlet discovered in the drugstore
- The search for El Dorado
- The Antiques Roadshow
These are all stories built around the discovery tale. Usually, the tales result in untold millions for the "discoverers": the family who found the Bugatti will be getting nearly $4.5 million.
It is a compelling story. Except that it is totally unrealistic.
Don't get me wrong -- I really like these stories, too. As long as they are treated as fun, fantastical tales.
When the discovery tale becomes a personal strategy for wealth or success, it is a problem. It is deadly when it becomes a build-it-and-they-will-come business strategy.
It is a problem in two ways. First, it promotes faith in a highly unlikely outcome. What do I mean? Let's be generous and suppose that there are 100,000 Bugattis (or Rembrandts or jackpots or stock certificates) in the world. Only a fraction of those Lotto tickets are going to be found in any one year (it took nearly 50 years for the family to find the Bugatti - there's a reason that such discoveries are so rare and notable). Again, let's be generous and assume that 5% of these (5,000 or so) are discovered per year.
At this point, there is literally a one-in-a-million chance that you will be the discoverer of the next Bugatti in 2009. And that's after being generous with our assumptions.
If you are now tinkering with the assumptions -- "Maybe there are really a million Bugattis and there's really a 20% chance of finding one..." -- please STOP. It is nice to hope, but it is destructive to manipulate the odds in order to justify hoping.
The second big problem with discovery tale strategies is that they are passive. Discovery tales encourage waiting and hoping as a substitute for industry and ingenuity. People put off getting a better job or starting their own business while they wait for "things" to get better or for their lottery ticket to come in.
So am I a total cynic? No.
Everyone has undiscovered treasure. But you don't find it. You use it. Your treasure lies in your hands and between your ears. You are the garage -- go make your rare Bugatti.
[where: United Kingdom]